|
Cancer Monthly News and CancerWire
|
|
|
|
|
Greetings!
In this edition of CancerWire we focus on
four new studies:
* The traditional Chinese herb Scutellaria (called
skullcaps in the West) contains a combination of plant
chemicals that together can significantly slow the
growth of several different cancers, according to a
study published in the January 2009 issue of Planta
Medica.
* Adding a mushroom extract to interferon therapy for
prostate cancer significantly improves the treatment's
effectiveness, and may help reduce both its cost and
side effects, according to a study published in the
Journal of Hematology and Oncology.
* An herb many Americans take to get an energy
boost might also help doctors treat one of the most
common-and deadly-cancers. Researchers have
discovered that ginseng, particularly when heated,
may be very effective against colorectal cancer,
according to a study in The American Journal of
Chinese Medicine.
* Why are the overwhelming number of studies on
natural products and cancer performed in cells and
animals and not patients? In a recent study that
appeared in the journal Complementary Therapies in
Medicine, the authors conclude that rigorous trials are
necessary to explore the effectiveness of Chinese
herbal medicines. In a special Editor's Note the
reason why rigorous trials have not been performed is
suggested.
Disclaimer - Please Read: None of
the information in CancerWire is a
substitute for professional medical advice,
examination, diagnosis or treatment and you
should always seek the advice of your
physician or other qualified health
professional before starting any new
treatment or making any changes to an
existing treatment. No information contained
in Cancer Monthly or CancerWire including the
information below, should be used to
diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease
without the supervision of a medical
doctor.
|
Herb Kills Cancer Cells
|
|
The traditional Chinese herb Scutellaria (called
skullcaps in the West) contains a combination of plant
chemicals that together can significantly slow the
growth of several different cancers, according to a
study published in the January 2009 issue of Planta
Medica.
The authors say this herb might prove an important
addition to current cancer treatments. "On the basis of
our preliminary results, we expect maximum benefit
from Scutellaria
in combination with standard
therapy such as surgery, chemotherapy, and
immunotherapy," says Prahlad Parajuli, PhD,
assistant professor in the Department of
Neurosurgery at Wayne State University and
Karmanos Cancer Institute in Detroit, Michigan.
Past studies have shown that Scutellaria has potent
antibacterial, anti-inflammatory, and anti-cancer
properties, which come primarily from natural plant
chemicals (phytochemicals) called flavonoids. Most of
the research conducted on Scutellaria so far has
focused on the roots of the herb, which are rich in the
flavonoid wogonin. However, the leaves and stems
are also thought to be high in cancer-fighting
phytochemicals, according to study co-author Nirmal
Joshee, PhD, assistant professor of Plant Science at
Fort Valley State University in Georgia.
To learn more about this herb and how it might
combat cancer, the researchers analyzed leaf, stem,
and root extracts from 13 different Scutellaria species.
They found that each extract contained different
combinations of six flavonoids: apigenin, baicalein,
baicalin, chrysin, scutellarein, and wogonin. Most
extracts contained three or four different flavonoids.
Two extracts contained all six flavonoids.
They then treated human breast, prostate, and brain
cancer cells, as well as non-cancerous cells, with the
Scutellaria extracts. Nine of the extracts significantly
halted the spread of cancer cells. The higher the dose
and longer the duration of treatment, the more
effectively the extracts killed cancer cells. Four
extracts-all from the Scutellaria leaf-were
particularly effective at triggering the death (apoptosis)
of brain cancer cells.
The researchers also looked at how the flavonoids in
Scutellaria-both individually and in combination-
affected cancer cells. A combination of four flavonoids,
each at a low dose, blocked the growth of brain cancer
cells by almost 50 percent. However, when those
same flavonoids were given individually at the same
dose, they had no effect on the cancer, which
suggests that each one possesses a different anti-
cancer mechanism and the effects are amplified
when the different flavonoids work together.
Future studies will help determine which combination,
or combinations of phytochemicals have the greatest
cancer-fighting ability. "Combining phytochemicals
with synergistic anti-cancer activity would allow use of
individual components at a very low dose, which
would eliminate or reduce toxicity," explains Dr.
Parajuli.
Certain flavonoids in Scutellaria also appeared to
target specific types of cancer. For example, baicalein
significantly slowed the growth of brain cancer cells.
This may be because individual flavonoids affect
mechanisms that are unique to each cancer, the
authors say.
Based on the promising results of studies done so
far, the researchers say they may launch a human
clinical study to investigate Scutellaria as an adjuvant
cancer treatment within a few years.
Source:
Parajuli P, Joshee N, Rimando AM, Mittal S, Yadav AK.
In vitro antitumor mechanisms of various Scutellaria
extracts and constituent flavonoids. Planta Medica.
2009;75:41-48.
|
|
Prostate Cancer and Maitake Mushroom
|
|
Adding a mushroom extract to interferon therapy for
prostate cancer significantly improves the treatment's
effectiveness, and may help reduce both its cost and
side effects, according to a study published in the
Journal of Hematology and Oncology.
Prostate cancer is the second deadliest cancer
among elderly men in the United States. Although
treatments such as surgery, chemotherapy, radiation,
and hormone therapy are available, their benefits
aren't always long-lasting, they can have significant
side effects, and the disease can return. Another
treatment option is immunotherapy with a class of
drugs known as interferons. These drugs provoke the
body's immune system to respond against the
cancer, and they are thought to inhibit the cancer cells'
ability to grow and differentiate. However, studies on
interferons have shown mixed results.
"The efficacy of these interferons has not been as
good as we expected and also they are rather
expensive," says study author Sensuke Konno, PhD,
associate professor in the Department of Urology at
New York Medical College.
To improve the effectiveness of interferons and reduce
the cost of treatment, researchers have been looking
at combining these drugs with other substances. Dr.
Konno investigated a treatment combining interferon-
alpha with D-fraction (PDF), an extract from the
maitake mushroom (Grifola frondosa). Past studies
have shown that this extract can stimulate an immune
response against cancer cells. Dr. Konno and his
team wanted to find out if the two substances
combined might have a synergistic effect on prostate
cancer cells.
The authors tested out the two substances, first alone
and then together, on prostate cancer cells in the
laboratory. Individually the interferon and mushroom
extract had no real effects on the cancer, except in very
high doses. However, when the two substances were
combined, they slowed the growth of prostate cancer
cells by up to 65 percent. The combination of the two
substances effectively halted the cancer cell cycle,
preventing the prostate cancer cells from dividing and
multiplying.
Combining interferon-alpha and PDF also reduced
the amount of each drug that was needed. Interferon
was reduced to one-fifth of its original dose. "It is thus
plausible that PDF may not only help potentiate the
interferon activity, but also help cut the cost down,"
says Dr. Konno.
Dr. Konno is cautiously optimistic about the possibility
of using combinations of interferon and PDF or other
substances in the future. "Although the combination of
interferon and PDF in our study looks good and
promising, I try to be a little more cautious because
this is an in vitro study (using cell cultures) and we still
have a long way to go," he explains. The next step in
the research would be to test out this treatment
combination on animals with cancer to determine the
appropriate dose, and learn whether it might cause
any unwanted side effects. Depending on the results
of animal studies, the combination therapy might
move forward into human clinical trials.
Source:
Pyo P, Louie B, Rajamahanty S, Choudhury M, Konno
S. Possible immunotherapeutic potentiation with D-
Fraction in prostate cancer cells. J Hematol Oncol.
2008;1:25.
|
|
Colorectal Cancer and Ginseng
|
|
An herb many Americans take to get an energy boost
might also help doctors treat one of the most
common-and deadly-cancers. Researchers have
discovered that ginseng, particularly when heated,
may be very effective against colorectal cancer,
according to a study in The American Journal of
Chinese Medicine.
Colorectal cancer is one of the most common types of
cancer in the United States, and among the deadliest.
Half of patients diagnosed with colorectal cancer
eventually die from the disease, and less than 10
percent of patients with colorectal cancer that has
spread will survive more than five years after
diagnosis.
Because chemotherapy and other standard
treatments aren't always effective and may have
serious side effects, many patients have turned to
herbal remedies. Ginseng has been a staple of Asian
herbal medicine, and studies have indicated that it
might help not only prevent cancer, but also relieve
some of the side effects (such as nausea and
vomiting) of cancer therapies.
Ginseng comes in Asian and American varieties, both
of which contain active compounds called saponins,
which are responsible for the herb's anti-cancer
properties. Although Asian ginseng has a long history
of use, and research, American ginseng has not been
as well studied. Last year researchers at The
University of Chicago launched a $6 million effort
funded by the National Institutes of Health to
investigate the anti-cancer potential of American
ginseng.
As part of that study, the researchers treated human
colorectal cancer cells with extracts of American
ginseng berry and root that had been steam heated.
The steamed extracts increased the saponin activity,
and halted the cancer cells' growth by as much as 99
percent. Steaming the Chinese herb notoginseng
similarly increased its anti-cancer effect.
Although treatment with ginseng doesn't work as well
as chemotherapy, it might be an effective adjuvant
cancer treatment, says study author Chun-Su Yuan,
MD, PhD, Director of the Tang Center for Herbal
Medicine Research at The University of Chicago. "It
could be used together with chemotherapy to increase
its efficacy and also to reduce the chemotherapy side
effects," he says. "It possibly could be a single
compound that could be a new-generation cancer
drug."
Although ginseng doesn't have any noticeable
adverse effects in moderate doses, when given in
larger amounts patients have noted increased heart
rate, nausea, headaches, and difficulty sleeping,
among other symptoms. The challenge is to
determine the optimal dose, and figure out how to
deliver ginseng in the most effective way to target the
cancer cells without causing significant side effects.
Future research should help resolve these
issues. "We would like to start human trials in the
future," Dr. Yuan says. "Our initial results were
promising."
Currently researchers are only in the animal testing
phase, and Dr. Yuan does not recommend that
patients take ginseng supplements for cancer
prevention or treatment. Ginseng hasn't yet been
studied well enough for this purpose, and there is no
guarantee that the active components Dr. Yuan's team
identified in the study will be in any given bottle of
supplements.
If you are interested in taking ginseng be sure to
speak with your licensed healthcare practitioner.
Source:
Wang Chong-Zhi, Yuan Chun-Su. Potential role of
ginseng in the treatment of colorectal cancer. The
American Journal of Chinese Medicine. 2008;36:1019-
1028.
|
|
Chinese Herbs - More Research Needed
|
|
To ease treatment symptoms and improve quality of
life, many cancer patients turn to Chinese herbs and
other complementary remedies. Research conducted
so far on complementary treatments has not been
thorough enough to prove any benefits or identify
potential side effects, according to a recent study
published in Complementary Therapies in Medicine.
Up to 91 percent of cancer patients say they have tried
at least one complementary therapy, particularly
Chinese medicinal herbs. Although many people who
use herbal remedies are under the impression that
these treatments are natural and therefore safe, some
herbs can have side effects, and they may interact with
other medications, potentially decreasing their
effectiveness.
Human clinical trials can help illuminate the benefits
and risks of taking herbal remedies, yet very few high-
quality studies have been done. When researchers at
the University of Manchester in England reviewed the
clinical trials on Chinese herbs for cancer, they
discovered only 49 studies, and all but one were
poorly designed and reported.
Although there are many reasons as to why more
thorough studies on complementary cancer therapies
aren't being undertaken, money is one of the biggest
problems. "The difficulty in securing funding is the key
issue, as there is a need to compete with all other
studies, and these studies on herbs seem to be of
low priority," explains Alexander Molassiotis, RN, MSc,
PhD, professor of Cancer & Supportive Care at the
University of Manchester.
Most of the studies that have been done originated in
China, suggesting that Western doctors aren't fully on
board with herbal remedies. "Conventional medicine
is unconvinced about the use of herbs and worried
about their use," says Professor Molassiotis. "There is
much negative press around such treatments. Also
there is a difficulty understanding a different medical
philosophy, such as that of Chinese
medicine."
The studies that have been done on complementary
Chinese therapies - though not of the highest quality -
do suggest some benefit to cancer patients. Some
studies have indicated that Chinese herbs can help
relieve the side effects of conventional cancer
treatments, while others have found that they improve
symptoms and quality of life in cancer patients. A few
studies have even suggested that Chinese herbs
might slow cancer growth and improve patient
survival. None of the studies included in this review
noted any side effects from the use of herbs.
The results of existing studies are promising, but
better quality research is needed to confirm any real
benefits, say the authors of the review. "It seems that
certain herbs could assist in the management of side
effects and improve the quality of life in cancer
patients, but current evidence is not enough to change
practice," says Professor Molassiotis. "Rigorous trials
are necessary to explore the effectiveness of Chinese
herbal medicines."
Source:
Molassiotis A, Potrata B, Cheng KKF. A systematic
review of the effectiveness of Chinese herbal
medication in symptom management and
improvement of quality in life in adult cancer patients.
Complementary Therapies in Medicine. 2009;17:92-
120.
Editor's Note:
This study underscores the fact that while herbs and
other natural supplements may prove to be safe and
effective to manage cancer, more research is
needed. The question is why has this research not
been completed. Unfortunately, the answer is
economic, not scientific. To a large extent,
pharmaceutical companies determine what potential
cancer therapies will be studied and funded with the
estimated 300 million dollars required to take a
therapy through clinical trials. But, no drug company
will spend that amount of money on a therapy that
cannot be patented. Because Chinese herbs and
other natural supplements exist in nature and were
not created in a laboratory they are very difficult to
patent. If they cannot be patented they cannot be
owned by a corporation. If they cannot be owned by a
corporation why would a company invest money to
bring it to market? This fundamental economic
dilemma may be the reason why there are no 100%
whole natural supplements approved for the treatment
of cancer.
|
|
Products & Services for Patients and Professionals
|
|
Messages from Cancer Monthly Sponsors:
Nutritional Support
Haelan Products offers Haelan 951, an
international award-winning, super nutritious,
fermented soybean protein beverage. Clinical
research and numerous reports from doctors and
cancer patients have demonstrated that Haelan 951
helps protect cancer patients from the toxic
side-effects of chemotherapy and radiation
treatments. In addition, one study found that the
soy isoflavone genistein (which is found in
Haelan
951) produced greater apoptosis with both
chemotherapy and radiation treatments. Apoptosis
means "programmed cell death" and it is a goal of
most orthodox cancer therapies. Because
Haelan 951
is a nutritional supplement, not a cancer
treatment,
it was used in this study to offset the
toxicity of
the treatments, not as a cancer therapy. http://www.haelan9
51.com
Immune Boosting Products
Get Healthy Again.com - This company
provides
a variety of immune boosting nutritional
supplements
designed to enhance the immune system.
http://www.health-reports.com/cancer-
conquest.html
Legal Services
Brain Cancer Misdiagnosis Information
Center
- Brain Cancer Misdiagnosis Information Center
provides information on the frequency of brain
cancer misdiagnosis, how you can find out if you
have been misdiagnosed, and what you can do about
it. The Center is run by the law firm of Webb,
Scarmozzino & Gunter. http://www.brai
ncancerlaw.com
Goldberg, Persky & White, P.C. - This law
firm (and its predecessor law firms) has been a
pioneer in asbestos litigation in the United
States.
The attorneys of Goldberg, Persky & White, P.C.
(GPW) have been involved in asbestos and
mesothelioma lawsuits since 1978. Their
experienced
mesothelioma lawyers participated in the
gathering
of evidence, such as the testimony of corporate
executives and doctors, and the accumulation of
corporate documents, that helped create the basis
for successfully suing the asbestos industry. GPW
has represented thousands of mesothelioma, lung
cancer, and asbestosis victims. Because of their
involvement in asbestos litigation from the
beginning, GPW has a clear understanding of
what is
required to succeed. In addition to outstanding
trial experience, GPW is backed by a large
arsenal
of corporate documents, depositions, and medical
articles with which to vigorously prosecute your
asbestos case. http://www.gpwlaw.
com/cm
|
|
Your Message Seen by Thousands of Patients & Clinicians
|
|
Every month, CancerWire reaches thousands of
cancer patients and
clinicians who care about alternative
and integrative therapies, immune and nutritional
support, new approaches to care, and other products
and services that can genuinely improve their quality
of life. If you have such a
product or service we can help you get the word out.
To learn more send an e-mail to:
info@cancermonthly.com
|
|
|